Call for a FREE Consultation

Offices in NY & NJ

Mike Quiat Comments

Mike Quiat Comments:

One of the most disturbing aspects of ERISA disability insurance law is the discretionary clause which plagues claimants in most states. While 11 states have relieved their residents of this unfair burden by legally banning the clause, 39 states have failed to do so. See list below.

The discretionary clause gives insurance companies the right to determine which claims they will pay. Because of judicial rulings interpreting the discretionary clause an impartial, judicial determination is extremely difficult to obtain for an ERISA claimant whose claim the insurer denies.

Having been instrumental in having the insurance authorities in New Jersey announce their strong opposition to the discretionary clause and to follow up with an administrative regulation outlawing the use of the clause as a matter of law, I am now trying to have the clause banned in all states in the interest of fairness and for the protection of their respective ERISA disability insurance consumers.

Understanding ERISA Claims

To understand the need for such a campaign, one must understand that if there is no statute or properly approved administrative rule banning the use of the discretionary clause in insurance policies, then courts on appeal are bound to honor the insurer’s discretionary decision unless it is “arbitrary and capricious”, a standard a claimant is hard-pressed to prove in a court of law.

To try to even things up for ERISA disability income insurance claimants so they get a fair shake on a claim, I am trying to get the New York State Insurance Department to issue an administrative rule banning the discretionary clause in New York. One would think this would not be difficult after the Insurance Department clearly came down on the side of doing away with the clause in some statements it published in 2006. The New York Insurance Department said, without reservation at that time, that the discretionary clause was against the public policy of the State of New York and should be prohibited.

It is now three years later and no action has been taken by State authorities which would legally and effectively do away with the discretionary clause for the benefit of New York citizens. See the New York Law Journal article. I intend to keep up the pressure until the Insurance Department or the New York Legislature takes the action necessary to legally rid the people of New York of this unfair policy clause once and for all.

Petition Your State Insurance Department

Disability lawyers in new Jersey - flag and scalesMeanwhile, I hope to inspire people in all other states to start petitioning their state insurance departments and their legislators to take binding legislative or administrative action to ban the unfair discretionary clause policy provision. I would be happy to provide anyone undertaking this cause in his or her state with sample legislation or administrative rules to make their efforts easier.

Our latest information shows the following states have legally banned the use of the discretionary clause by health insurance companies:

California, Hawaii, Illinois, Indiana, Maine, Michigan, Montana, New Jersey, Oregon, Utah and Wyoming. The 39 others have not.

Contacting Your State Insurance Authority

For your convenience in making your discretionary clause feelings known to the insurance authorities in your state, just click on your state for complete contact information.

Request a
Free Consultation

  • captcha

Mike Quiat Comments

What Our Clients Say

  • Mr. Quiat was very specific about my options, chances of a successful appeal, and the costs of same. We did discuss the possibility of taking […]

    ~ Kevin

    unum disability claims
  • Mr. Quiat, and his Team were able to re-instate my disability benefits discontinued by Aetna Insurance. Mr. Quiat was always available, and responded quickly to […]

    ~ Carlos

    unum disability claims
  • Mr. Quiat . Is thorough , pleasant to work with . He exhibits complete competency of his profession . I would highly recommend him . […]

    ~ Insurance Client

    unum disability claims
  • Mike took the time in our initial meeting to truly understand my situation and what I was up against. He listened to my concerns and […]

    ~ Kevin

    unum disability claims
  • As I was facing some of the most difficult times of my life with seemingly no way out, I was most fortunate to meet Michael […]

    ~ Long Term Disability Client

    unum disability claims
  • HE IS THE BEST!!!! He listened very intently to me and took copious notes. At the end of my meeting with him I knew that […]

    ~ Arbitration Client

    unum disability claims
  • GREAT ADVOCATE, CARING, HIGHLY ATTENTIVE, NOT GREED DRIVEN.
    Michael Quiat handled my long term disability case and did so in a very caring manner. […]

    ~ Barbara

    unum disability claims
  • TOP OF THE LIST OF ATTORNEYS Mr. Quiat responded to all of my phone calls and emails in a timely manner. Mr. He is very […]

    ~ Insurance Client

    unum disability claims
  • SOLID EXPERTISE Solid expertise… Very responsive in client concerns\Effective advocate in handling interactions with opposing party.

    ~ Employee Benefits Client

    unum disability claims
  • THE MOST RESPONSIVE ATTORNEY Mike stands out as the most responsive attorney…He always made it as easy as possible for me to get things done, […]

    ~ Insurance Client

    unum disability claims
  • EXTRAORDINARY ATTORNEY Mike Quiat is an extraordinary attorney…His extensive experience and expertise was instrumental in obtaining and maintaining my LTD benefits… The compassion he showed […]

    ~ LTD Client

    unum disability claims
  • WE NEVER HAD TO GO TO COURT Mr. Quiat took over the case, and, due to a combination of his meticulous attention to detail in […]

    ~ Insurance Client

    unum disability claims
  • EXCELLENT!They were very professional, responsive to my questions, and successfully represented me with my claim. I would highly recommend Michael Eli Quiat and Joe Russo […]

    ~ LTD Client

    unum disability claims
  • WELL PREPARED AND PRESENTED Mr. Quiat’s appeal on my behalf was so well prepared and presented there is no doubt something like this is best […]

    ~ Insurance Client

    unum disability claims
  • MIKE GOT RESULTS I’ve worked with many attorneys over the course of my business career. Mr. Quiat is not only knowledgeable and capable, but also […]

    ~ Insurance Client

    unum disability claims
  • WE SUED AND WON… My disability insurance company stopped paying me. We sued and won and Mike got my payments reinstated… I trusted Mike completely, […]

    ~ Insurance Client

    unum disability claims
  • GENUINE CONCERN FOR THE CLIENT I have personally seen Mike Quiat in action on ERISA long term disability cases. Mike takes a personal interest in […]

    ~ Insurance Client

    unum disability claims
  • I NEVER HAD A PROBLEM… I have found him to be experienced, knowledgeable, but not over-bearing … I never had a problem getting appointments, reaching […]

    ~ Employee Benefits Client

    unum disability claims
  • THE HIGHEST REGARD… Michael and his staff have always been very professional, polite, and well informed. … I have nothing but the highest regard for […]

    ~ Contracts Client

    unum disability claims
  • RESPECT AND COMPASSION… I was very scared, anxious, intimidated and unsure of how to handle a particular disability insurance claim with a big company.Mike immediately […]

    ~ Arbitration Client

    unum disability claims
  • “CAN DO” ATTITUDE… When my wife and I met Mr. Quiat my life was in turmoil. Mike sat us down and very calmly listened …When […]

    ~ Insurance Client

    unum disability claims
unum claims New York ERISA Attorney

Professional Affiliations

Areas Served :

Proudly serving all of New York and New Jersey.